Doctor Thorne by Anthony Trollope

Doctor Thorne1858. Kindle ebook. 661 pages.

Review:

I heard about the #6Barsets reading project from JoAnn at Lakeside Musing. I believe she did succeed in reading all of the Chronicles of Barsetshire this year. Inspired by the project, I managed to get one book further in the series with the completion of the third book, Doctor Thorne, having read The Warden and Barchester Towers some years ago. I absolutely adore these books, but their length and the lures of other books lead to my procrastination.

Trollope’s combination of warmth, humor, and insight into the human mind has few peers in literature, or at least in my affection! In Doctor Thorne, these skills are applied to the story of Doctor Thorne, his ward and niece, Mary, and their array of friends, family and acquaintances. Doctor Thorne is a man of deep integrity and stubborn pride. Mary is an intelligent young woman who is loved by her childhood friend, Frank Gresham. Unfortunately, Frank’s family is besieged by debt and so he “must marry money.” The characters go through many trials, but most come to a happy ending in the end. Trollope knows he has sewn it all up rather neatly, I think, based on his various asides. I must add that part of the joy of reading Trollope’s novels is encountering his flippancy about plot and novel structure, his little lectures and tangents, his pointed favoritism toward certain characters:

As Dr Thorne is our hero – or I should say my hero, a privilege of selecting for themselves in this respect being left to all my readers – and as Miss Mary Thorne is to be our heroine, a point on which no choice whatsoever is left to any one, it is necessary that they shall be introduced and explained and described in a proper, formal manner.

Mary Thorne is definitely a character one can root for. She reminded me a lot of Mary Garth, of Middlemarch, both young women capable of great love but also possessing firm knowledge of their own self-worth. They are not cowed by those deemed superior in rank.

It’s the kind of book where I don’t want to review it as much as I want to chat with someone else who has read it, and compare notes on what parts we liked best, and what we thought of such-and-such character. For instance, there’s this one almost throwaway part that I love where one of Dr. Thorne’s domestic staff smacks a guest’s servant with a rolling pin when he is inappropriately amorous of her. It’s a nice small moment of satisfaction as the guest himself is causing Dr. Thorne no end of great trouble. Then too, I would want to discuss how well Trollope captures the way that wounded pride motivates people to say or not say certain things, to let their friendships lapse and connections fray.

I heard that Julian Fellowes has been tapped to adapt Doctor Thorne as a three-part series airing in 2016. Apparently, he’s a big fan of Trollope and counts him as an influence. As much as Downton Abbey can be a mixed bag, I am hopeful that Trollope’s excellent source material will bring out the best in Fellowes. I couldn’t find who has been cast as Mary Thorne, but I saw that Alison Brie will play the great character of Martha Dunstable (who apparently will be American in Fellowes’ adaptation.) Tom Hollander (Mr. Collins in 2005’s Pride and Prejudice) will play Doctor Thorne. Ian McShane has been cast as the ambitious, alcoholic Sir Roger Scatcherd.

So, looking forward to that and also to reading the rest of the Barsetshire Chronicles in the near-ish future!

Advertisements

9 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

9 responses to “Doctor Thorne by Anthony Trollope

  1. I’ve read the first two books in the Chronicles of Barsetshire, so this one will be next for me. I too love Trollope’s asides to the reader. I wonder how (or if) that will be conveyed in the miniseries…exciting to hear that is in the works!

    • I have a feeling Trollope’s authorial tangents and asides may be cut out. That said, I’ve seen mini-series adaptations slip in some of the author’s voice via voice-overs, as with the 2007 Northanger Abbey and the 2009 Emma.

  2. I absolutely adored this book… and remember laughing out loud at the rolling pin incident. Can not agree more with your statement about not wanting to review, but rather just chat with others who have read it. I’ve felt that way about the entire series. We’ve been talking on twitter as we read and it’s been SO much fun!

    I just finished The Last Chronicle of Barset during my 2 week bout with bronchitis and a sinus infection. I’m usually terrible with series, but this one has been a pleasure. Trollope may just be my new favorite author!

    I’m sure Trollope has provided Fellowes with plenty of fodder for an outstanding miniseries!

  3. Yes, the rolling pin incident! That would be priceless to see on screen. I’d view turning Miss Dunstable American with caution, but it could work. The Barsetshire books would certainly lend themselves to satisfying book chat. They create such a full, convincing world with characters that feel like our friends and neighbors.

    • I’m also a little wary of the change of Miss Dunstable to being an American. I hope that doesn’t become an overly pronounced plot point, and that it’s just an incidental aspect that doesn’t change the essential character of Miss Dunstable in any way.

  4. Fay

    Ian McShane should get to chew some scenery as Sir Roger Scatcherd. Looking forward to that. Enjoyed your comments here, especially since I just re-read the novel earlier this year.

  5. Pingback: Joining the Classics Club | A Good Stopping Point

Join the Discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s